|
Times Square In Penang, Is It For Real?
By Luk4all.com.my Editor
Posted
26th March 2007
A
visit to the Penang Property Fair is quite an
eye opening. Not only it boasted some of the
most expensive housing projects in Penang (with
a tag price of RM1,000,000 on a 2,000 square
feet apartment, can’t even find this in KL), but
it also showcased many other projects in the
island to meet the ever growing demands of
housing properties. Most of them do have their
own selling point and target market segment, but
one of them definitely caught our attention,
“Times Square”.
Times Square…does the name ring a bell? The
first impression that falls upon most people is
the lighted and animated advertisements at the
junction of Broadway Avenue in New York City,
which is already an iconic world landmark and
has become the symbol of the home city itself.
The vibrant, alive and neon filled city of
lights at Times Square New York City, USA.
Well, that’s on the global front. Locally, Times
Squares would remind most of us to the Berjaya
Times Square in Kuala Lumpur. It is unmistakably
the most popular name among Malaysian as it is
tagged as the world’s largest building ever
built in a single phase, with 7.5 million square
feet of built up floor area. It is the place
that offers shopping, luxury accommodation,
business, food and abundant of entertainment.
Currently it has space for more than 1000 retail
shops (even though many are still vacant).
Berjaya Times Square in KL
However, Times Square in Penang? That is
something new and exciting to blog about, is it
not?
The
Penang Times Square is a RM700 million
development projects located in the heart of
historic Georgetown. It will boast 800 units of
residential units, commercial spaces, exhibition
centre, hotel and office blocks and 2 acre of
urban open square similar to the European town
squares. It is also part of the Penang
government’s urban renewal effort which is
regarded as the milestone project for the 200
year old Georgetown. An ambitious project that
if successful, will rival the Bukit Bintang in
KL and Orchard Road in Singapore, as it is
strategically located near the Komtar Centre,
famed food districts and 3 international
star-rated hotels within 100 meters radius.
Penang Times Square location in the heart of
Georgetown.
Thus, the big question remains… Does Penang
Times Square really has what it takes to make an
impact and recreate Georgetown? Can Penang be
iconize as the shopping and entertainment haven
in Malaysia, and bring back the shine of Pearl
of the Orient? Will it convince investors to buy
into the idea and the grand vision?
When we last checked at Penang Property Fair,
80% of the apartment units and almost all
commercials units have been sold out, at least
the number proves this is true..
Is this a project too huge for the developer to
handle, as we’re talking about massive scale of
development and it will not be a white elephant
project at the end of the day?
These are tough questions even for rocket
scientists; however we will try our best to shed
some lights on our thoughts.
1)
Traffic jam around Jalan Dato Keramat
needs to be resolved. Most Penangites are
reluctant to drive to Georgetown due to this
reason. Since the opening of the new Jelutong
Highway, it is able to ease the traffic a
little. But with the scale of the project, it
will need a full proof solution—public
transportation, such as monorail, in the future.
The accessibility to Times Square is the heart
and soul of the project success.
a.
Verdict – The 9th Malaysian
Plan has already approved the monorail project
in Penang, with Times Square as one of the sub
station on its route. The completion of the
monorail project will definitely boost the
attraction to Times Square specifically and
Georgetown in general.
2)
There are already too many shopping malls in
Penang, an approximately 4 big malls in the
island itself. Times Square would need to be
different from the rest of the malls in order to
attract shoppers and tourists. Having said
that, according to the developer there is
already a plan for a square (including the
European town squares) which will stage shows or
celebrations. It will also be used for grand
festive celebrations such as Christmas and New
Year. That is quite a new concept, as we have
yet to see this at any malls in Penang. This
would provide a complement to the compulsory
branded retails shops and also the management’s
quality of the mall. This is an innovative idea
to be different from the rest of the market
players.
a.
Verdict – We believe this would actually
work and it will bring a positive impact to the
project.
3)
The current poor condition on the pre-war
buildings surrounding Penang Times Squares needs
to be renovated and repainted to give a
refreshing new aura and image to Georgetown.
Look at Boat Quay and Clarke Quay in Singapore,
the government put in a lot of efforts in
preserving these buildings and manages to
overturn it into a well known tourist
attraction.
a.
Verdict – This is a long shot looking at
the current state of the pre-war building in
Penang. The Penang government has yet to come up
with a concrete steps to tackle this old
problem. There is a hope that, the Penang Times
Square success would spur the development and
effort being put in to rejuvenate the old
pre-war buildings.

Boat Quay and Clarke Quay in Singapore.
In summary, this is not only an ordinary project
in Georgetown (most of Penangites regarded it as
mere another new mall and residential units).
The success of the Penang Times Squares will
also indirectly propel the development of the
Georgetown area, as well as the rejuvenation of
the area such as Campbell streets, Penang Road,
Little India and etc. As more development
projects moving south (due to Bayan Lepas FTZ
and future second Penang Bridge Link), Penang
Times Square is seen as the masterpiece project
in Penang that will bring back the glory days of
Georgetown… and Penang.
Back to the question…does Penang Times Square
has what it takes to be a success? We guess it
might, after all.
Comments:
I totally agree, Penangites need a "bulls eye" at the heart of Georgetown to bring back its heyday. Another suggestion that i have is to bring back the tram (it's a train carriage that run parellel to the road, just like the tram in San Francisco) to Georgetown.
I think i still notice the steel rail on the road on Penang Road (in front of Odean Cinema). It could one hell of a tourist attraction, and who knows it might even reduces traffic jams.
3/25/2007 8:25:05 PM | penang kia
I think the Penang Times Square will play a significant role in Penang's development especially in easing the traffic congestion at Georgetown once the monorial system is functioning. Penangites too might save up some time and cost on car fuel. Good idea.
3/26/2007 3:36:59 PM | Rajas
so its time to snap up the times square properties? And further more the property gain tax is currently being abolished. any advise?
3/26/2007 8:25:23 PM | times_square?
Well, it could be a good bet to invest (at least i'm one of the buyer of the service apartment) As the last time i check, all the commercial lots have been snapped up. Even the residential units are 90% sold out.
If you can afford somewhere RM300K and above property, i think you can consider about putting your money here. And Penang property price has been skyrocket all these years. A RM200K apartment 5 years ago, is now at least worth RM50K more, that's how good the Penang property price is.
3/26/2007 9:36:12 PM | brethern
Brethern, could it be a typo error ? RM200k becomes RM500K ? I am not sure which area are you referring ? To be honest, not many apartments or condo in Penang are making good money. In fact, many of them are loosing money. Take for example, E Park, Sunnyville, some of these so-called "above average class" residential areas are now at least 20% below price than the purchase price. So, investing in Penang must be careful.
Friend of mine bought a condo at Bayswater Resort Condo(just opposite of Tesco Penang), facing seaside and Penang bridge at RM300K of purchase price, Vacant possession by Jun 07 and OC by end 07, now fetch at RM400K and above. This is the best investment of condo class in Penang. They had sold off all the units during the soft launch. This area is planning to become the next Pulau Tikus in the next 10 years infrastructure blue print. Nearby has many shops such as Starbuck, &-11 and etc. Inside Tesco has banks, Pos office, Court, and many outlets apart from the Tesco Hypermart.
So, some loosing money and some earn great money over short period.
Callum....KL
3/27/2007 9:08:39 PM | Callum
Nope, not a typo. I might have a short sighted on the property price in Penang, but have a few friends who bought the apartment at Villa Emas in Bayan Baru(and also the new apartment beside it), initially it was around RM200K, now it fetches RM250K. Most probably the price jack-up could be due to the new Queensbay Mall. By the way, the only property that can goes up by 2X (RM200K to RM500K) in Penang is only landed properties. At the current price rate in Penang, the cheapest you can find for a double storey terrace is >RM500K. Well, that's only for millionaires, for most people, just dream on.
3/27/2007 9:32:01 PM | brethern
I have also been thinking about investing in properties. I guess it is the same when you invest in properties or stocks. It is very important to choose the correct developer and location. I think all of us know pretty well who developed sunny ville, e-park and who developed bayswater. The overall package of the development is very important. Anyway my aunt who has sunny ville (bought for investment) was complaining about it, but after she fully furnished it and renting it out for 1.3K a month, she has stop complaining :), and that is about 8% returns. Whether times square will succeed or not will depend on the whole package, and that includes that monorail.
3/28/2007 7:27:28 AM | properties
further record.... regency height - buying from developer, at 198K to 290K, now selling 280K to 350K, sunrise garden - buying from developer at 181K, now selling at 260K, villa emas previously at 180K now selling at 250K after queensbay mall is up. Its all about developer, the overall package and the quality of the project. Buy the right property and you will make your money.
3/28/2007 8:23:33 AM | properties
If u observed carefully, you can see that many Penang apartment or condo are quite run down. The property management is important as they are appointted by the developer for maintaining the building landscaping, infrastructure. If u happens to go inside Sunnyville, in the past, Sunnyville is quite a high class condo, but today is very run down. I have seen the best and well maintain condo in Penang is Parkview (built by IJM) at Bukit Jambul next to Lakeside/Alpine tower (also built by IJM). The living condition is very impressive and conducive. This is the kind of property that we should be looking for investment.
I fully agreed that any projects that are develop near to shopping complex such as Tesco, Queensbay etc will certainly fetch a better price, however, we shall also consider the upkeep of the building. I am sure no one wants to see your apartment or condo runs down over a decade or so, in particularly those apartment rented out to Bangladeshy or Indos.
3/31/2007 2:13:14 PM | Callum
It's time to take a paradigm shift on property investment in penang island. Why not look at the mainland where landed properties is way below or less than half the price per square foot for an apartment on the island. And feedbacks from apartment dwellers on poor maintenance and rundown properties is mainly a concern. Having to park your cars on multi storey carparks, carrying your groceries all the way to your unit some couple of floors only to realise that your house keys is in your car. Now that really pisses me off. I understand that there are some value for money landed properties on the mainland especially at the sungai dua area where a 2 1/2 storey unit is only selling at less than 240k with a 2000+ built up area. With this 2000+ in penang, you will be paying 300+ maintenance fee for life for a condo. And that area is also toll free, within mins. to carrefour, pacific hypermart, jpj, hospital. And golfers take only 15mins to penang golf resort! Now this is really value for money. Check it out. This is quality living.
5/30/2007 5:15:18 PM | jawsam
I do agree. I have been living in Butterworth for the last 20 years. And compare to the living standard (in term of property), you can get a 3X better property (bigger, luxurios ..etc) in the mainland. And you don't have to stuck in the jam travelling around the island (well, except the penang bridge, of course). A 5 mins away destination can take almost 1 hour to get during rush hour. This is madness!!
Well, i think Tambun area is definitely a good bet. And not to forget Juru as well, since Autocity is there and it is the most happening place currently in Penang (island included).
5/31/2007 12:48:38 AM | maverick
Everything you do has the other side of coin. staying in terrace house are more prone to robbery attacks. This has been rampant in most places in Malaysia.
5/31/2007 11:19:45 AM | Callum
Post your comments
|